The assault on a Srinagar man for raising pro-Modi slogans at Jantar Mantar shows that intolerance has no party colour
A young man from Srinagar went to Jantar Mantar on Wednesday and shouted slogans in support of the Prime Minister. For this, he was allegedly dragged, pushed and beaten outside a restaurant in Connaught Place, in full view of cameras, by people taking part in the opposition protest against the Election Commission. Fahim Nazir says he abused no one. He has challenged anyone to produce a video showing otherwise. No such video has surfaced. What has surfaced is a clip of a lone man being hit repeatedly by a crowd.
Strip the politics away and the facts are simple. A citizen expressed a political opinion in a public place. Others disagreed with it. Instead of answering him, they attacked him. That is the whole story, and it is a disgraceful one.
It does not matter whose supporter he was. It does not matter whose protest it was. A man who shouts for Modi has the same right to the street as a man who shouts against him. The Constitution does not grant free speech only to those whose views the crowd approves of. The moment a political gathering decides that an opposing voice must be silenced with fists, that gathering stops being a protest and becomes a mob.
The irony here is hard to miss. The protest was about protecting the vote. The vote is the most basic form of political expression. Yet the same crowd could not tolerate a single contrary slogan for a few minutes. One cannot march for democracy in the morning and beat up a dissenter in the afternoon.
Those who defend such assaults by pointing to attacks carried out by the other side are missing the point entirely. Kashmiris have been beaten in Lucknow, Dehradun and elsewhere for being Kashmiri. Journalists have been thrashed at this very Jantar Mantar. Each incident has been used by one camp to excuse the next. This is how extremism works. It does not need a single ideology. It only needs the belief that the other side deserves it. One act of violence becomes the justification for another, and the cycle never ends. There is no good extremism and bad extremism. There is only extremism, and it feeds on itself.
Political parties must also take responsibility. Appealing to rivals not to disturb a protest is fair. Allowing or excusing violence when they do is not. Leaders who want to be trusted with power must first show they can control their own crowds.
The video exists. The faces are visible. Delhi Police must register a case, identify the attackers and prosecute them. Anything less will tell every crowd in the country that beating a dissenter carries no cost.
Fahim Nazir may be a Modi supporter. On Wednesday, he was simply a citizen who was beaten for speaking. That should trouble everyone, whichever side they are on.