The Night Had No Answer:How Kulgam’s Silence Exposed the End of Militancy’s Grip

BB Desk

I. Ahmad Wani

Follow the Buzz Bytes channel on WhatsApp

ان کی آنکھوں میں کھٹکتا ہے اجالا کیسا

وہ جو شب زاد ہیں، سورج سے خفا رہتے ہیں

Un ki aankhon mein khatakta hai ujala kaisa

Woh jo shab-zaad hain, suraj se khafa rehte hain

The poet’s taunt is aimed at those who cannot bear the sight of dawn. For three decades, such men decided when Kashmir would open its shops and when it would bury its sons. Last week in Kulgam, someone lit the lamp anyway. The night had no answer.

Count the days. On November 11, gunmen fired on a CRPF checkpoint at Akhran in Kulgam, injuring three jawans. On November 16, security forces killed one of the two accused, Umar Nisar Dar. On November 18, they cornered the second, Lashkar-e-Taiba commander Mohammad Lateef Bhat, inside a mosque at Zangalpora village. From attack to closure, it took seven days. Having reported on Kashmir since 2009, I remember cases that dragged on for years—and many that were never closed at all.

Look at how the forces did it. No single agency acted alone. The Army’s 9 Rashtriya Rifles, the Jammu and Kashmir Police, and the CRPF operated as one cohesive unit. They combed through CCTV footage, questioned hundreds of people, and searched village after village. When they finally traced Bhat, they did not storm in. The Kulgam SSP and Army officers spoke to him over a video call, urging him to lay down his rifle. He was 22. He had a way out. By the police account, he refused and opened fire. Only then did the forces end it.

That restraint deserves notice. A state that offers surrender before it fires is a state sure of its ground. It does not need a body to prove its strength. It wanted a young man alive, and it said so on camera. The choice to die was his.

What followed, however, is the real story. No one issued a protest call. No hartal was observed. Not a single stone was thrown. Contrast this with 2016, when the killing of one militant commander shut the Valley down for months and cost scores of lives. Back then, funerals drew thousands of mourners, fiery slogans, and gun salutes—turning every burial into a recruitment rally for the next batch of boys. This week, Bhat was buried around 10 at night in a remote village in Kupwara, roughly 160 kilometres from his home in Khrewan. A handful of relatives stood by the grave. By morning, it was an ordinary day in Kulgam.

Sceptics will argue the silence was enforced. They will point out that the body was withheld and the burial carried out far away under tight security. That is true, and it is deliberate policy. Yet policy can only prevent a funeral procession; it cannot force a shopkeeper to lift his shutter or keep a teenager’s hand off a stone. Curfews and restrictions failed to achieve that in 2008, 2010, and 2016. People stayed calm this week because they chose to.

My reading of that choice is simple: Kashmiris have done the arithmetic. Thirty years of the gun yielded graveyards, widows, orphans, shut schools, and a lost generation. The men who scripted the slogans rarely paid the price; ordinary families did. Bhat’s own father had reported him missing a year ago, and this week he had to identify his son’s body in Srinagar. No parent in the Valley wants to make that journey.

Religion has long been the oldest tool in this trade. Bhat reportedly told the officers pleading with him that he was going to God. The Valley has heard that line for three decades—and it has seen who truly profits from it. Investigators say his handlers sit safely across the border, risking nothing. They sent a young tradesman from Khrewan, a college dropout, to kill a policeman and two migrant labourers, as the police charge, and ultimately to die inside a mosque. Kashmir’s faith, shaped by its saints and shrines, teaches life. Nobody here is fooled any longer when murder is dressed up as worship.

So what changed? In my view, the turning point was August 2019. One can debate much of what followed the abrogation of Article 370, and this newspaper has never hesitated to question governments. But on terrorism, the doctrine since then has been unambiguous. Union Home Minister Amit Shah and the Lieutenant Governor’s administration have held firm: no talks under the shadow of the gun, no public funerals for militants, and no mercy for the ecosystem that feeds, shelters, and funds them. Forces that once worked in separate silos now share both intelligence and credit. The results are visible on the streets. Stone-pelting, once a weekly ritual, has vanished. The hartal calendar is history.

Shah described Bhat as Lashkar’s last known active local militant in the Valley. If that holds, it marks a historic shift. Only a few years ago, local boys joined militant ranks by the dozen each year. Today, by the government’s count, the outfit’s local roster is empty.

Still, one nail does not seal a coffin. Foreign militants continue to lurk in the forests, and the Pahalgam massacre of April 2025 showed the devastation even a few of them can inflict. The men orchestrating this proxy war from across the border will inevitably hunt for the next Lateef Bhat. Complacency would be the first gift we hand them.

Moreover, the gun is only half the battle. Having won the security argument, the state must now win the peace. The young man who rejects militancy needs employment, fair recruitment, and an administration that listens. Hundreds were questioned during this manhunt, and Bhat’s relatives spent days in an interrogation centre. The innocent among them deserve a word of regret and the restoration of their dignity. Promises made to the people of Jammu and Kashmir must be honoured. A population that has turned its back on terror must feel that the state stands with them, not over them.

Kulgam has sent an unmistakable message this week. The attacker of a CRPF post could not survive even eight days on the run. His death stirred no crowd; his slogans found no echo. The lamp has been lit, and those who feared the morning had nothing left to say. May this prove to be the final nail in the coffin of terrorism. Whether it does depends on all of us: the forces that guard the lamp, the government that must keep it fuelled, and the people who have finally chosen the light.

Blurb

A CRPF post was attacked on November 11. Seven days later, the accused was dead and buried by night, and the Valley did not stir. That quiet says more than any speech.