The Whisper in the World’s Noise: On Bashir Dada’s Wihij Wunal
Peerzada Mumsrat Shah
Bashir Dada is not merely a critic of literature; he is a cartographer of the quiet heart. With a career spanning over two decades, Dada has established himself as one of our most perceptive and patient literary voices, renowned for his ability to trace the subtle, often unspoken emotional currents that give a work of art its enduring power. A scholar of modern lyrical fiction and post-colonial narratives of identity and memory, Dada approaches criticism not as dissection, but as an act of empathetic excavation. His reviews are less about judgement and more about understanding—creating a resonant space where a book’s soul can be fully heard.
Dada’s own body of work reflects this profound sensitivity. His acclaimed collection of literary essays, Echoes in the Attic: On Memory and Forgetting (2015), is considered a seminal text on how contemporary literature from the subcontinent grapples with personal and collective history. His later work, The Grammar of Longing (2021), a series of meditations on love, absence, and the prose of poets like Faiz and Dickinson, solidified his reputation as a writer who treats emotional states with the precision of a linguist. For Dada, a book is not an object to be consumed, but a companion to be conversed with. It is this unique, contemplative approach that he brings to his review of the quietly remarkable Wihij Wunal.
—
In an era defined by the clamour of hot takes, algorithmic recommendations, and literature that often shouts to be heard, the arrival of Wihij Wunal feels less like a publication and more like a subtle, profound homecoming. This is not a book that arrives with fanfare; it seeps in. It does not commandeer your attention but earns it, page by quiet page, through a rare and resonant emotional honesty. To read Wihij Wunal is to engage in an act of deep listening—to its characters, to its silences, and, ultimately, to the quietest chambers of one’s own heart. It is a work that masterfully demonstrates how stories can cease to be mere narratives and instead become spaces—homes—where the most delicate of human feelings are not just described, but respectfully housed.
The most striking attribute of Wihij Wunal is its foundational quietude. From the very first story, the text establishes a rhythm that is anathema to modern narrative impulses. There is no urgency here, no plot-driven race toward revelation or resolution. Instead, the book operates on the logic of memory and emotion, allowing feelings to unfold with the natural, unhurried pace of thought. This deliberate pacing is not a lack of action, but a different kind of action—an internal one. The stories are built not on dramatic events, but on the seismic shifts that occur within the human spirit in the aftermath of a glance, a memory, a long-held silence. The author understands that the most transformative moments in a life are often the quietest: the weight of an unspoken word, the hollow shape of an absence, the gentle persistence of a love that has learned to speak in whispers.
This reverence for stillness transforms silence from a mere absence of sound into a primary language of the text. In Wihij Wunal, silence is articulate. It is the space between lovers where everything and nothing is said; it is the years stretching between a loss and its acceptance; it is the quiet companionship of shared but unvoiced understanding. The book posits that our deepest truths are often those we lack the words for, and in that lack, a more honest communication can occur. It “gives value to stillness, reminding us that silence is not emptiness—it is often where the heart speaks most honestly.” This philosophical core elevates the collection from a simple set of tales to a meditative experience. We are not just reading about characters who are silent; we are invited into that silence ourselves, asked to participate in the unspoken, to feel the volume of what is withheld.
The characters who inhabit this quiet world are its greatest achievement. They are rendered with such acute, unassuming familiarity that they feel less like literary creations and more like echoes of people we have known—or indeed, facets of ourselves. They are not heroes of epic sagas but individuals navigating the intimate, universal territories of love, longing, patience, and regret. Their joys are “restrained, their sorrows quiet, yet their emotional truth is overwhelming.” We meet the person holding a decades-old letter, not with dramatic weeping, but with a tired, knowing smile. We encounter love not in grand declarations, but in the daily, patient act of remembering, in the choice to hold a space for someone who may never return. This emotional maturity is the book’s steel spine. Wihij Wunal “does not romanticize pain, nor does it seek easy comfort.” It acknowledges the complex, often bittersweet tapestry of human connection, where love and longing are inextricably woven with loss and incompleteness. The stories offer no facile solutions or neat closures; they offer something rarer and more valuable: understanding. They sit beside the reader in their own incompleteness, creating a powerful sense of solidarity.
This effect is magnified by the book’s prose, which is itself a quiet marvel. The description of it moving “like a gentle Kashmiri wuchh—a breeze that does not disturb but awakens” is perfectly apt. The language is lyrical yet never ornate, evocative but never forceful. It carries “the scent of nostalgia and the warmth of affection that has survived time.” Sentences flow with a poetic cadence that feels innate, not constructed, as if the emotions themselves have found their most natural linguistic form. This stylistic gentleness is a form of profound respect—for the subject matter and for the reader. It trusts the reader to lean in, to listen closely, to feel deeply without being manipulated by hyperbolic language or melodramatic cues. The prose becomes the perfect vessel for the book’s themes, proving that power does not always reside in volume, but often in precision and tenderness.
The thematic heart of Wihij Wunal is its exploration of love and longing as enduring, patient states of being. Here, love is stripped of all performative glitter. It is not a fiery explosion but a slow, sustaining burn. It is found in loyalty, in the act of keeping a memory alive, in the quiet resilience of a heart that refuses to fully let go, even when logic dictates it must. This portrayal is both heartbreaking and deeply affirming. It suggests that love’s truest measure is not in its possession but in its persistence; not in how loudly it proclaims itself, but in how long it can endure in silence. This reframes longing from a state of lack to a state of devotion, making the characters’ quiet endurance feel not pathetic, but noble and deeply human.
Consequently, reading Wihij Wunal becomes a uniquely personal experience. The book’s lack of narrative imposition and its focus on universal inner experience create a vacuum that the reader’s own heart rushes to fill. The stories feel “less like a narrative and more like a confession whispered to the reader.” This intimate address fosters a profound sense of identification. The characters’ unspoken thoughts begin to mirror our own; their silent aches resonate with private memories we had shelved away. This is why the book “lingers.” It attaches itself not to our critical mind but to our emotional subconscious. Lines return to us in idle moments; the mood of a story colours our afternoon; a character’s resigned smile feels intimately recognizable. The book achieves that magical, elusive goal of literature: it makes the reader feel seen, not in their grand triumphs, but in their quiet, private vulnerabilities.
In the context of contemporary literature, Wihij Wunal is a quiet but firm act of resistance. “In an age where literature is often reduced to trends and quick consumption,” it steadfastly “chooses depth over speed, tenderness over spectacle.” It is an antidote to the curated emotional extremes of much of modern storytelling. It rejects the notion that to be impactful, a story must be shocking, traumatic, or globally consequential. It asserts, with quiet confidence, that the most consequential battles are fought within the human soul, in the everyday choices to remember, to hope, and to endure. It “reminds us why stories matter—not because they entertain, but because they reflect who we are when no one is watching.”
To conclude, Wihij Wunal is more than a book; it is a sanctuary. It is “a space where love rests, where longing is understood, and where silence is allowed to speak.” It is a work of profound emotional intelligence and artistic integrity that does not seek to dazzle its audience but to accompany them. It is, as the original reflection so beautifully notes, a book to be read slowly, remembered deeply, and returned to—a literary hearth for the heart. Some books are indeed written, and some are felt. Wihij Wunal is a rare creation that is both: meticulously crafted as literature and immediately absorbed as feeling. It is a quiet masterpiece that, long after the final page, continues to echo, having quietly, irrevocably, become a part of you.
