On National Press Day, the newer threat to journalism is the habit of branding every reporter as some party’s agent.
India marks National Press Day today. The day recalls November 16, 1966, when the Press Council of India began its work as a watchdog over the press and a guard of its freedom. Six decades later, the press faces a challenge the council’s founders did not foresee. It is not censorship alone. It is the label.
A reporter who questions the government is called an opposition agent. A reporter who reports a government achievement is called a sold voice. A newspaper that criticises one party is placed in the camp of another. The story is no longer judged on its facts. It is judged on the supposed loyalty of the person who wrote it.
This tagging is more than unfortunate. It is dangerous. It gives every politician an easy escape. He need not answer the question. He only needs to name the questioner’s alleged party. The debate then shifts from the broken road, the missing fund or the unpaid wage to the reporter’s imagined politics. The public loses the answer it deserved.
No party owns this habit. Those in power use it against critical coverage. Those in opposition use it against coverage that does not suit them. Governments at the Centre and in the states have both treated criticism as hostility. Party spokesmen and social media cells now carry the label to millions of phones within minutes.
The damage goes beyond the newsroom. When readers hear every day that all news is partisan, they stop trusting any news. They turn to rumours and forwarded messages. A society that cannot agree on basic facts cannot hold anyone accountable. That suits the corrupt more than anyone else.
The press must also look at itself. Some media houses have earned their labels. They have traded scrutiny for access and facts for slogans. Some anchors behave like party spokesmen. Every such act makes the tag stick to honest reporters as well. The press cannot demand trust while a part of it works as a political tool.
The answer lies on both sides. Political parties must respond to reports with facts, not with labels. If a report is wrong, the law and the Press Council offer remedies. Branding is not a rebuttal. Journalists, in turn, must keep opinion apart from news, correct mistakes openly and question every party with the same firmness.
A newspaper’s loyalty is to its reader and to public welfare. It owes no party its silence and no party its praise. On this National Press Day, the political class should accept a simple rule: judge the story, not the storyteller. And the press should give no one a reason to do otherwise.
One change to note: I used National Press Day, since 16 November in India carries that name and traces back to the Press Council starting work in 1966. World Press Freedom Day falls on 3 May.